Tuesday, November 04, 2008

Determining My Presidential Vote

When determining for whom to cast my vote, I look for the candidate who will most closely uphold the Constitution of the United States (and his state constitution, if a state office). But the Constitution is merely the framework of government. The Declaration of Independence defines the purpose of government: “to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men”.

What rights are to be secured? The Declaration tells us that governments secure “inalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.”

So when a candidate takes an oath to uphold the Constitution they are taking an oath to secure these inalienable rights.

While no candidate perfectly embodies the principles of the Declaration, I will cast my vote for President on behalf of Senator John McCain for the following reasons:

Life:
John McCain holds to the scientific fact that life begins at conception. Barak Obama says that knowing when life begins or when one obtains rights is above his pay grade. But if you do not know when life or rights begin then how do you know that the very abortion policies you uphold do not end a life or deny a right? While McCain is wrong to support embryonic stem cell research, he is far and away closer to holding the inalienable right of life than Obama.

Second, McCain would appoint judges who hold to the intent of the Constitutional Framers and therefore the Declaration. Obama would appoint judges who have “empathy”. Empathy may be in the scope of the legislative branch but it is not within the purpose of judges. Judges are to wield justice based on a standard which is defined in our Constitution.

If judges can make up what the Constitution says as the go along (the living document concept) then a mini Constitutional Convention convenes every time the judges meet. Plus, one wonders why there was a need to have a section on Amendments in the Constitution.
Advantage: McCain

Liberty:
Obama says he will “fundamentally transform America.” A fundamental is the foundation or the essential elements of something. Our nation’s foundation is stated in the Declaration of Independence. If you “fundamentally transform” something you are changing it’s foundation. Obama doesn’t say explicitly how he will “fundamentally transform America” but we have some clues.

For example, his “spread the wealth” comment. Are we really supposed to believe that the Founders believed the government should take money from those who earned it and give it to those who didn’t earn it? Especially given that they did not institute an income tax but raised revenue through tariffs. How is using the force of government to take money from you and give it to me an example of Liberty? That’s not liberty. That’s compulsion.
Advantage: McCain

Pursuit of Happiness:
The Founders didn’t mean by happiness that I do whatever I want. They meant the pursuit of the common good. They recognized that only a limited government could pursue the common good. They were afraid of a strong central government. This was why our first government was framed under the Articles of Confederation. The Articles, however, provided for too weak of a government. However, the Constitution was nearly not ratified because of fears that it would lead to too strong a government.

McCain has been a staunch opponent of pork spending and, for the most part, limiting government to it’s constitutional framework. Obama wants to increase government drastically – universal health care, universal pre-school, etc. Obama wants to raise taxes not to raise revenue but for “fairness”. But it is only “fair” to those of whom he approves.
Advantage: McCain

Conclusion:
Senator McCain is much closer to the principles of the Declaration and the Constitution which secures them than is Senator Obama. It is not even close. That is why I am voting for John McCain to be our next President of the United States.

Previous posts on the Presidential race:
Spreading the Wealth
Senator Obama’s Halloween Message
The Columbian Endorses Obama
Columbian Endorses Obama – Pt. 2
Columbian Endorses Obama – Leadership
Columbian Endorses Obama – Judgment
Columbian Endorses Obama – Iraq War

Updated: To add links for the Previous Post section.

Columbian Endorses Obama - Iraq War

This is the fifth in a series of comments regarding The Columbian’s endorsement in the presidential campaign.

The Columbian claims that “any successful reformer must excel in leadership and judgment. In the past several months Obama has distanced himself as the superior candidate in those two areas.”



On the Iraq War, The Columbian says “Obama prefers a quicker withdrawal of troops than we would like, but his proven leadership and solid judgment indicate he can resolve the Iraq dilemma collaboratively.”

Collaboratively means to work together. With whom exactly will Obama work that hasn’t already been done by the current administration?

Iraq? Pakistan? England? Great Britain? Already being done.

The UN? An organization which sits thugs on its Human Rights commission, routinely turns it s head from human rights violations (e.g. Darfur), has done nothing to stop Hezbollah rocket attacks into Israel, ran the Iraq Food for Oil scandal, and had at least 16 resolutions against Iraq and their weapons program.

France? Profiters from the Oil for Food scandal under Chirac. Maybe now under Sarkozy who wishes to work more closely with the U.S. than Chirac. But then that occurred under the current administration which is working with France.

al-Qaeda? As was famously pointed out, what would Obama say that would change their minds about killing us? Would he charm them with his intelligence, with his eloquence, with his movie star good-looks?

Obama, in fact, staunchly opposed the surge, a strategy recommended by General Petraeus and supported by Senator McCain. Obama continued to claim it was the wrong strategy even after it was clear the surge was working.

Then, when the situation on the ground in Iraq was becoming stable and the Iraqi’s started talking of a timetable for U.S. troop withdrawal, Obama audaciously claimed that the Iraqi’s were agreeing with his view that there needed to be a timetable on withdraw. But the Iraqi’s only talked about a timetable because the situation had improved so drastically; an improvement that came about by the very surge policy that Obama opposed.

Put another way, had Obama’s position prevailed the violence in Iraq would have continued (what was going to stop it – talk?). Or we would have left and Iraq would have likely descended into civil war where thousands of innocent people would have perished including those Iraqis who had the courage to stand along side us.

McCain was right. Obama was wrong. Where was Obama’s solid judgment. Obama went with the left wing anti-war wing of his party and with the way the country was leaning. McCain said the right thing to do is the surge even if it is not popular. He listened to the military leaders on the ground. Obama listened to what was politically expedient.

It was McCain who showed “proven leadership and solid judgment” not Obama.

And let’s not forget Obama’s “proven leadership and solid judgment” when Russia went deep into Georgia territory in their conflict over South Ossetia. As Reuters reported, Obama stated, “Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint”

That’s like telling both the rapist and victim “to show restraint”.

The Columbian only provided sweeping generalizations in their endorsement of Obama. They provided no examples (i.e. evidence) to support their generalizations because the facts (i.e. evidence) would show their generalizations to be suspect.

McCain has proven his leadership over his years in the Senate, as a Navy fighter pilot, and as a POW. As this series has shown in the examples provided, McCain has shown solid judgment on the most critical issues of our time.

When intellectually honest people actually look at the FACTS it becomes clear that John McCain is far and above more qualified to lead the greatest nation on earth than Barak Obama.



Previous posts:
The Columbian Endorses Obama
Columbian Endorses Obama – Pt. 2
Columbian Endorses Obama – Leadership
Columbian Endorses Obama – Judgment


Updated: To add links for the Previous Post section.

Columbian Endorses Obama - Judgment

This is the fourth in a series of comments regarding The Columbian’s endorsement in the presidential campaign.

The Columbian claims that “any successful reformer must excel in leadership and judgment. In the past several months Obama has distanced himself as the superior candidate in those two areas.”


Regarding judgment, The Columbian claims that “Obama chose a running mate who neither hurt him in the polls nor diverted the spotlight from the main man on the ticket. McCain’s choice has done neither.”

Really? This is the main criteria for picking a Vice-President? A person who will be one heartbeat from the most powerful office in the world?

What shows greater leadership and judgment, picking someone who you think is the best person for the job even if it takes the spotlight from you or hurts you in the polls? Or picking someone who may be qualified but won’t divert you attention from yourself or hurt you in the polls. The first is a pick based on what is best for the country. The latter is a choice of political expediency. You tell me which shows greater leadership and judgment.

Second, the man he picked to bolster his lack of foreign policy, Joe Biden, voted against the first Gulf War to liberate Kuwait even though the UN and our allies were also in favor. He proposed dividing Iraq into ethnic partitions.

During the VP debate, Biden looked into the camera and told the country that Obama “did not say he’d sit down with Ahmadinejad” without preconditions even though Biden criticized Obama at the time on this very point. Further, Biden claimed that we “along with France” kicked Hezbollah out of Lebanon”, a reality that may have been realized in the Mirror universe on Star Trek but never occurred in ours.

McCain, in stark contrast, picked someone who immediately energized the Republican party and who he allowed to outshine him. Immediately, she was attacked by the media who published all sorts of unconfirmed rumors. She was demeaned as being stupid and not ready to be “a heartbeat” from the presidency even though she had a proven track record as a “successful reformer” (remember the Columbian’s criteria) and more executive experience than Obama who was running as the heartbeat of the presidency.

Neither Palin or Obama has any Foreign policy experience. That’s why Obama picked Joe Biden. So in an Obama presidency, foreign policy experience that has continually been wrong will be one heartbeat from the presidency. In a McCain presidency, foreign policy experience that has a track record of being right will be the heartbeat of the presidency.

When you care more about whether you are in the spotlight or if you will be hurt in the polls than the facts don’t matter.


Previous posts:
The Columbian Endorses Obama
Columbian Endorses Obama – Pt. 2
Columbian Endorses Obama – Leadership


Updated: To add links for the Previous Posts section.

Columbian Endorses Obama - Leadership

This is the third in a series of comments regarding The Columbian’s endorsement in the presidential campaign.

The Columbian claims that “any successful reformer must excel in leadership and judgment. In the past several months Obama has distanced himself as the superior candidate in those two areas.”

For leadership, they claim that Obama has united his own Democratic Party “even reaching beyond his party to speak to all Americans. McCain, in stark contrast, continues to slog through a fractious Republican Party that often is his worst enemy.”

Two problems exist with this assessment.

First, this is contradictory. A reformer often must fight their very own party. That’s the point. Reform comes from standing on principle against those who only care about their own self-interests. McCain has often gone against his own party standing upon the principles of what is good for the country. When you go against the powers to be, of course, there will be disunity.

Where has Obama ever gone against his party’s leadership? Where has he stood up and said “No!” to Pelosi and Reid? When you simply go along with others, of course, you are united with them. That’s what being united means! But it also means you are not necessarily a reformer.

Therefore, based on The Columbian’s own standard, that a “successful reformer must excel in leadership”, Obama fails the leadership criteria for being a successful reformer.

Second, if McCain is truly “slog[ging] through a fractious Republican Party” has is it that Obama continues to claim that McCain has sided with Bush over 90% of the time. In fact, the Democratic strategy has been to tie any Republican Congressional incumbent to Bush. In other words, the Republicans are united!

So if Obama’s claim is true about McCain then the Columbian’s claim that the Republican Party is rebellious, unruly, and irritable is false. If The Columbian’s claim is true then Obama and the Democratic Party are engaged in a lie. Either way, Obama fails to pass The Columbian’s own standard.

Previous posts:
The Columbian Endorses Obama
Columbian Endorses Obama – Pt. 2

Monday, November 03, 2008

Madelyn Payne Dunham 1922-2008

My sympathies go out to Senator Obama and his family tonight for the loss of their beloved grandmother. Of Dunham, Obama said:
"She's the one who taught me about hard work," he said. "She's the one who put off buying a new car or a new dress for herself so that I could have a better life. She poured everything she had into me."
Obama announced Dunham's passing to a rally by saying, "She's gone home." Losing a loved one is very difficult and even more so when they have had such an impact in one's life. Obama's comments tell us two things about the way the world actually is.

First, this life is about relationships. We can impact another's life for good or for ill. Dunham and her husband made a choice to be there for a young Obama when his parents, for whatever reason, were not.

Second, there is a comfort to knowing that our loved ones have "gone home". There remains a longing for them; an emptiness in their absence. But a peace also exists in knowing that, having turned our face toward our Creator, our loved ones live on where there is no more pain, no more suffering. There is only life.

I pray that in this difficult time for the Obama family that their memories of this beloved woman bring them comfort.

Columbian Endorses Obama - Pt. 2

I posted previously on The Columbian’s “no distinguishable impact” endorsement of Senator Barak Obama. They claimed that their opinion was “offered more to stimulate conversation than to change minds.” See The Columbian Endorses Obama for why their claim is specious.

I suspect their real motive was to provide cover for the audacious reasons The Columbian has for endorsing Obama.

They are quick to give a disclaimer that they “are wary of a few past relationships [Obama’s] had with controversial figures. McCain carries that same baggage to a lesser degree.”

Yet The Columbian provides no examples of these relationships for either candidate. They simply throw out a generalization with no corresponding evidence.

What do the following have in common besides having relationships with Senator Obama: Rev. Jeremiah Wright, William Ayers, Father Michael Pfleger, Khalid al-Mansour, Kwame Kilpatrick, Louis Farrakhan, Tony Rezko, Rashid Khalidi, Raila Odinga.

The answer: Each has, in word and/or deed, expressed hatred for America. Some are explicit anti-Semites.

Are we to believe that Senator McCain has had relationships with haters of America? Really?

The Obama camp says that these were just happenstances of history, coincidences of bumping into these individuals while going about his life.

How is it, then, that Obama continually bumped into those who haters of America? How is it that McCain, 25 years older, has not happened upon anti-American individuals time after time? Could it be because Obama runs in those circles and McCain does not?

It speaks volumes that the only way The Columbian can make their endorsement seem credible is to smear Obama’s opposition.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Senator Obama's Halloween Message

Barak Obama's short 2008 Halloween message*:

America, this is our moment. This is our time. As we celebrate Halloween at this defining moment for our nation we must remember that:

When you spread the wealth around, it's good for everybody (TRICK on those who earned the money!).

I want to make sure that everybody who is behind you, that they've got a chance for success (TREAT for those who didn't earn the wealth!)


TRICK or Treat, America! Now go out and have a safe and Happy Halloween.



*NOTE: The Obama campaign did not actually release this statement. It is, however, a composite of statements made by Senator Obama. References:

"America, this is our moment. This is our time" - "Obama's Nomination Victory Speech In St. Paul," The Huffington Post, June 3, 2008.

"At this defining moment for our nation" - "Obama's Nomination Victory Speech In St. Paul," The Huffington Post, June 3, 2008.

"I think when you spread the wealth around, it's good for everybody" - "Obama fires a 'Robin Hood' Warning Shot", New York Post, October 15, 2008.

"I want to make sure that everybody who is behind you, that they've got a chance for success" - "Obama fires a 'Robin Hood' Warning Shot", New York Post, October 15, 2008.

Also see post: Spreading the Wealth

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Pro-Abortion on Humans; Pro-Life On Animals - Part 2

A friend of mine, Don Grant, received an email link from a colleague, Lisa Frost, for a letter to the editor she wrote that was published in the Siskiyou Daily News (Ashland, OR). Following is Mr. Grant’s response to Ms. Frost’s points. The exchange clarifies the opposing sides on the issue of life.

This is Part 2 of a two-part series on their dialogue.
For Part 1, see Pro-Abortion on Humans, Pro-Life on Animals - Part 1


Lisa Frost’s Follow-up:

I'm sorry you have become so right winged minded. Perhaps you have been with your partner(s) too long. I'm referring to your religious spouse and republican business partner.

I am not only pro choice, but pro abortion as a means of birth control. I am also anti-illegal immigration and anti-Palin.

Palin doesn't study or read. She couldn't even name a periodical that she has read in the Couric interview. Research her educational background. Listen to her talk "doggone it." She's an opportunist and anti environmentalist.

"...and you betcha" drilling would only satisfy 3% of our needs anyway. Why destroy the last frontier for this meager amount of oil.

Population growth is the main culprit of the environmental demise. Vote Obama/Badin for change and hope. Sorry to hear you have changed so drastically. We have certainly grown apart in our ideologies.

Lisa



Don Grant’s Follow-up:

Lisa,

You cannot expect to send out a mass e-mailing containing unsupportable liberal dribble without at least one person disagreeing with your ideology and responding to it. As I recall, I wasn’t the only person to respond to your comments. In a democracy, there needs to be a dialogue about political and ideological issues. It’s not just a one-way street. If you expect everyone to agree with you, then the discussion becomes a monologue not a dialogue. It’s simply a “circle jerk” amongst a group of persons who are afraid to dissent or to think and who get off on chatting deceptive slogans: “DRILL, DRILL, DRILL; KILL, KILL, KILL.”

From the e-mails of you and others, I can only assume the following:
  1. Liberals will sleep with Republicans, but will not have dinner with them under, ostensibly, the premises that no political intercourse can occur in the horizontal position;

  2. Liberals do not have an ethical or moral basis for much of their ideology either because
    (A) they refuse to think about morals and ethics;
    (B) they have a relativistic and inconsistent moral and ethical basis for their ideology; or
    (C) they are truly afraid to have their ethical and moral bankruptcy exposed for what it is;

  3. Liberals, despite their claim of “tolerance,” are very narrow-minded people who simply do not tolerate any dissent from their ideology or agendas;

  4. Liberals refuse to debate the issues on the facts, but almost always resort to ad hominen arguments, personal attacks, “red herring” arguments, name calling (instead of debating in an honest and intelligible fashion) which are logical fallacies most people learn to avoid in high school;

  5. Liberals get extremely upset when challenged to support their dribble on intelligible, moral and ethical bases;

  6. Liberals have an overriding ideology which drives which facts they use to support their arguments and, on many issues, which distorts the factual record in a biased manner;

  7. Liberals have a bankrupt moral and ethical basis for their screaming “choice” in opposing the protection of unborn and just born human life, yet decry hunting and killing animals and support the government’s becoming involved in other personal sexual decisions such as polygamy, sex with animals, and sex with minors because apparently liberals want the government involved in our sexual lives, but they want to define the extent of that involvement consistently with their ideology without any moral or ethical basis for this intrusion;

  8. Liberals vow to allow the indiscriminate killing of human life under guise of an ideology which believes that human life is bad for the planet and environment; thus a higher life form (human life) is sacrificed at the sacred alter of radical environmentalism.
Hey, this list could go on and on. I simply urge you to chant “THINK, THINK, THINK” instead of other mindless slogans and to really think about the ethical and moral basis for your liberal views.

I am not interested in receiving future e-mails from you which call me names such as “asshole,” and which suggest that I am influenced by my “religious wife” and “Republican business partner” when you, in fact, are ignorant of their true religious and political views.


Unlike many liberals, I arrive at my opinions after researching the issues and not by osmosis and not by simply copying the “talking points” of organizations.

Pro-Abortion on Humans; Pro-Life On Animals - Part 1

A friend of mine, Don Grant, received an email link from a colleague, Lisa Frost (attorney and member of the Animal Legal Defense Fund), regarding a letter to the editor she wrote that was published in the Siskiyou Daily News (Ashland, OR). Below is the link to Ms. Frost’s letter followed by Mr. Grant’s response.


This is Part 1 of a two-part series on their dialogue.

Lisa Frost’s Letter to the Editor:


Don Grant’s Response:

Hi Lisa:

Thank you for sending me your interesting “op piece” on Sarah Palin. It is fortunate that, in America, we can all express our opinions in public forums such as newspapers and over the Internet. However, I do not share some of the “ideology” of the National Resource Defense Council (NRDC) and the agenda set forth by similar organizations for a few of the reasons stated in this e-mail. Without necessarily disputing the facts in your “op piece” or knowing your “ideology” (even though I believe that “ideology” often drives our choice of “facts”), I simply offer the following comments:

KILL, KILL, KILL: Our society has an interesting, yet perverted, set of values when we can decry shooting a wolf, yet will smear candidates and anyone else who argues against the killing of millions of unborn and just born babies (human life). I certainly believe that animals should be treated humanely and not indiscriminately killed or used as testing objects, yet I suspect that the NRDC would not raise the same outcry for the slaughter of “human” animals under the slogans of “pro choice” and “constitutional rights.”

Slogans are just that: slogans. However, ethical and moral values must transcend the constitution and the ideologies of these organizations. If not, then our societal “moral” and “ethical” values are simply the function of a majority vote by the people or, as more often occurs, a 5-4 vote of a supreme court.

If the constitution permitted slavery (as it apparently once did because we now have the Thirteenth Amendment), then I doubt that we would be arguing that the “constitution” (or as it is interpreted by the ruling hegemony) embodies our appropriate moral and ethical values as a society and as individual thinkers.

Unfortunately, to the converse, “ideologies,” in our modern society (whether denoted liberal or conservative) too often transcend a careful factual, logical, ethical and moral analysis of many issues. Without a “sourced” moral and ethical basis, then society and, to a large extent, those who shout out their agenda the loudest, are left to a shifting set of values depending on those who have the “will to power” which produces a very parochial and nuanced view of morality and ethics without any analysis of the universal picture. I would be interested in your thoughts on these issues.



[1] Siskiyou Daily News, October 7, 2008, http://www.siskiyoudaily.com/opinions/letters_to_the_editor/x282363330

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

The Columbian Endorses Obama

The Columbian's (Vancouver, WA) editorial board endorsed Obama last week with the caveat - I kid you not - "Our opinion is only that, refuted by many, carrying no distinguishable impact. Our opinion is offered more to stimulate conversation than to change minds".[1] (emphasis mine)

According to Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary, one meaning of endorse is:
"2 a: to approve openly <endorse an idea> ; especially : to express
support or approval of publicly and definitely <endorse a mayoral
candidate> b: to recommend (as a product or service) usually for financial compensation endorsed by a pro basketball player>"[2]
The editorial board of this newspaper doesn't think they will influence anyone within their large circulation audience. If that's the case, why didn't the board say they are not endorsing anyone, list the major advantages and disadvantages of each candidate, and then leave it for discussion.

That's called good, professional, journalistic practice where one just reports the facts. Wait, that's what news articles are supposed to be. Opinion pieces, on the other hand, are where you take those facts and draw a conclusion! After all according to Merriam-Webster, the word opinion "implies a conclusion thought out yet open to dispute ."[3]

An editorial is done precisely to give one's reasons for their conclusion (in this case the Obama endorsement) that is then available to be disputed. The Columbian editorial board wants to be able to give their opinion without being held accountable for it.

That way, they influence people while brushing aside any criticism by saying "we were just trying to stimulate conversation".

That's intellectually dishonest.


[1] "In Our View: Obama for President", The Columbian, Oct. 16,2008.
http://www.columbian.com/article/20081016/OPINION02/710169982/-1/opinion
[2] Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/endorse
[3] Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/opinion

Saturday, October 18, 2008

Spreading the Wealth

Karl Marx[1]:

"From each, according to his ability; to each, according to his need."

Barak Obama[2]:

"I want to make sure that everybody who is behind you, that they've got a chance for success, too." (to each, according to his need)

I think when you spread the wealth around, it's good for everybody."
(from each, according to his ability)


[2] For Obama's entire statement, nContx, see the October 16, 2008 online article at the NY Post (nypost.com) http://www.nypost.com/seven/10152008/news/politics/obama_fires_a_robin_hood_warning_shot_133685.htm

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Brad Pitt Donates to Support Polygamy

E! Online reports that "Brad Pitt Shells Out in Support of Gay Marriage". Pitt states:
"Because no one has the right to deny another their life, even though they disagree with it, because everyone has the right to live the life they so desire if it doesn't harm another and because discrimination has no place in America, my vote will be for equality and against Proposition 8".
I'm curious as to Pitt's view on polygamy or polyamory. If he supports those then he would be consistent with his stated view. He would also be in the minority since very, very few same-sex marriage supporters advocate other types of relationships as marriage.

If Pitt rejects those relationships as being marriage, then why? After all, if "everyone has the right to live the life they so desire" and "discrimination has no place in America" then on what grounds, Brad - on what grounds - do you deny any type of relationship that human beings want to define as marriage?

What is this notion of equality for which you will cast your vote? Homosexuals already have the same rights to marriage as every other citizen. Everyone has the right to marry someone of the opposite gender. We all have equality.

Same-sex marriage advocates counter that homosexuals cannot marry whomever they want. If being able to marry whomever one wants is the criteria for marriage then same-sex marriage advocates should be supporting polygamy, sibling marriages, and plural marriages also.

Yet they do not!

With these relationships, same-sex marriage advocates suddenly become - well - quite traditional in their views on marriage.

Same-sex marriage isn't about equality. It is about legitimizing homosexual relationships by making them special in the same way as heterosexual relationships. Saying all relationships are special (i.e. equal) is - to paraphrase Dash in "The Incredibles":

"Another way of saying no [relationship] is."

I encourage everyone to vote for equality and in favor of Proposition 8. Vote to keep true marriage equality in the state of California.

ProtectMarriage.com
Scan of the Marriage Initiative

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Signing of the U.S. Constitution - Sept 17, 1787

Today, September 17th, 2008, is the 221st anniversary of the signing of the United States Constitution.

All 12 state delegations (Rhode Island was not represented) approved the Constitution. Thirty-nine (39) of the forty-two (42) delegates signed it at the Pennsylvania State House (now called Independence Hall) in Philadelphia. Following the signing the Constitutional Convention formally adjourned.

On June 21, 1788, (fully nine months later) the Constitution became effective for the ratifying states when New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify it.

The complete text of the United States Constitution - including background information on the different Articles and Sections - can be found at USConstitution.net.

Friday, September 05, 2008

Ellen Goodman: "Keep the killing of innocent human beings private"

In her September 3, 2008 column, Ellen Goodman not only critcizes Sarah Palin but she also attacks those who who oppose abortion:
"it's the right wing that made social issues into a political issue. The right wing decided that pregnancy was not a matter of private decision-making but a harsh and unrelenting political battle." (emphasis mine)
Perhaps, Goodman needs a history lesson. Prior to Roe v. Wade, the states - via their legislatures - (aka the political arena) were allowed to decide their own abortion policies. Most did not allow abortions but some, in the years preceding Roe, moved to liberalize their abortion statutes.

So abortion (or as Goodman refers to it, pregnancy as a "matter of private decision-making") was already a "political issue."

My question is this: Prior to the Roe decision was there "a harsh and unrelenting political battle" over abortion?

No, because the majority of Americans did not favor abortion. Roe (pushed by Goodman's side) federalized and took the issue from the people, and forced it down their collective throats. This coalesced the very group she now accuses of creating a "harsh and unrelenting political battle." Of course, one might also say Goodman's side created the "harsh and unrelenting political battle" by federalizing the issue in the first place.

Goodman also writes:
"the [Republican] party meeting in St. Paul, Minn., would put decisions about pregnancy in the hands of the government and replace sex information with disinformation. No, you don't have to pass judgment on a 17-year-old to pass judgment on these unrelenting policymakers." (emphasis mine)
Of course, this is a suprising moral judgement passed by Goodman, who earlier in her column criticized, "the 'family value' folks who have fashioned a political wedge out of moral judgements". Nope, no political wedge from Goodman. Not at all.

And to what disinformation does Goodman refer? She provides no evidence to backup her assertion. Time for a biology lesson. It is a scientific fact that the uniting of the human father's sperm with the human mother's egg results in a unique, living, human being. The scientific terminology for this union is conception. For anyone who doubts, see the slideshow at WebMd, "Conception: From egg to embryo".

When was the last time Ellen Goodman referred to that which resides in human mother's womb as a human being? If one refuses to discuss the basic, foundational, scientific fact of this whole issue, isn't that disinformation?

In fact, Goodman hides behind sterile words and phrases. Only twice in her 700 words does she use the word abortion, once calling John McCain, "an unrelenting opponent of abortion" and the other in reference to the Republican platform being opposed to "every abortion." The rest of the time Goodman talks about the right-wing being against pregnancy or against "private decision-making." Very sterile language she very clearly relates to an abortion.

But what is an abortion? It terminates a pregnancy. What does it mean to be pregnant? From Merriam-Webster's Medical Dictionary, to be pregnant means "containing a developing embryo, fetus, or unborn offspring within the body." In terminating a pregnancy, an abortion terminates the "unborn offspring within the body." What kind of offspring? In the case of the union of a human male's sperm and a human female's egg, the offspring is a human being.

But what of the part of the definition that says it is an embryo or fetus. Again from Merriam-Webster's Medical Dictionary:

embryo - "especially : the developing human individual from the time of implantation to the end of the eighth week after conception"
fetus - "specifically : a developing human from usually two months after conception to birth"

So "embryo" and "fetus" are medical terms that define stages of development not the type of being one is. So let's repeat Goodman's own words ripping the veil of her Orwellian language away to reveal the true meaning of her words:
"the party meeting in St. Paul, Minn., would put decisions about terminating the pregnancy (i.e. life of an innocent, defenseless, unborn human being) in the hands of the government and replace sex information with disinformation. No, you don't have to pass judgment on a 17-year-old to pass judgment on these unrelenting policymakers."
In other words, Ellen Goodman "pass(es) judgement on these unrelenting policymakers" who would dare try to save the life of an innocent human being!

But is it wrong for government to do so. One of this country's founding principles is

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men"
(Declaration of Independence)

Governments are instituted to secure certain unalienable rights, one of which is Life!

Not only does Ellen Goodman attack those who would destroy innocent human life but she attacks those who would use government to do the very thing it is instituted to do: Protect the unalienable right to Life!

Of course, Ellen Goodman
wants to keep this as a private decision. To hide the fact that she defends the killing of innocent, defenseless, unborn human beings.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Abortion vs Blood Transfusions

The following letter to the editor from Jackie Lane of Battle Ground (WA) appeared in the Aug 11 Columbian:

Horrified by right to decline
I am horrified to see that the Bush administration is attempting to expand the definition of the word “abortion” to include some forms of birth control.

I am horrified that the administration supports “right to decline,” allowing medical staff to refuse to inform women of their legitimate medical options based on the caregiver’s religious beliefs. By this logic, we can have physicians who do not believe in blood transfusions allowing people to die in emergency rooms because of their own religious objections.

I want the people who provide my medical care to have my best interests first and foremost, and I want them to communicate with me clearly and completely about my options.

The phrase "legitimate medical options" is a reference to abortion. What is an abortion? It is the termination of the being residing in the woman's womb. In other words, Lane is horrified that caregivers may refuse to inform women that they can kill their innocent, vulnerable, unborn child because it violates the caregivers' conscience.

So Lane is comparing a physician who refuses to provide a patient with a transfusion (albeit because of conscience) to a provider who refuses to inform a patient about abortion.

The problem is Lane's comparisons are not equivalent. Blood transfusions are given to save a patient's life. The overwhelmingly, vast majority (it's not even close) of abortions are done for convenience NOT to save a woman's life.

To deny the blood transfusion would be to deny life. To deny an abortion does not deny the woman her life. It also continues the life of the innocent, vulnerable, unborn child within her womb.

Monday, August 04, 2008

Founding of the U.S. Coast Guard - August 4, 1790

On this day in 1790, the U.S. Coast Guard was created by Congress, which authorized Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton to build a small fleet of ten cutters to protect the coast.


4 August

"1790-Congress authorized the Secretary of the Treasury Alexander Hamilton's proposal to build ten cutters to protect the new nation's revenue (Stat. L. 145, 175). Alternately known as the system of cutters, Revenue Service, and Revenue-Marine this service would officially be named the Revenue Cutter Service (12 Stat. L., 639) in 1863. The cutters were placed under the control of the Treasury Department. This date marks the officially recognized birthday of the Coast Guard."

For more information, visit the United States Coast Guard website.

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Forcing One's Morality on Others - Part IV

On May 28, 2008 the following letter to the editor by Paul Holmes appeared in the Columbian (Vancouver, WA) newspaper attacking Christianity's view of homosexual behavior. My comments are in italics:

This is the fourth in a four part series.

Paul Holmes writes:

And fourth, you are not being harmed by either gays or lesbians. Let others who do not believe as you do live their own lives with equal protection under the law.

If you must crusade, do so against divorce. In the Bible, Jesus actually is quoted regarding marriage, "so they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate." You have tens of millions of your fellow Christians whom you can re-convert."

Christians have and do "crusade" against divorce. And they are roundly criticized for doing so.

Further, Holmes only takes part of the passage from Matthew 19. Why did Jesus speak against divorce? Placing the passage in context gives us the answer.

Jesus stated, "Haven't you read that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'?

Then we come to the part Holmes quoted: "so they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate."

Jesus stated divorce is bad because the Creator made a man and a woman to come together as one in union. Divorce rips the union apart.

Thus, Christ clearly states the purpose of marriage is to bring together male and female. I have no doubts that Holmes lauds Christians (i.e. those who claim to follow the teachings of Christ) who support same-sex marriage even though it goes against the very reason Christ said marriage was created.

Yet, it is clear that Christians - again, those who claim they are followers of Jesus' teachings - who support same-sex marriage are rejecting Christ's clear teaching on marriage.

In doing so, they are refusing to conform themselves to the image of Christ in order to believe whatever their own hearts fancy.

Lastly, is the claim that we are not being harmed by gays and lesbians. Individually, no. But to the extent that anyone supports same-sex marriage does harm us because it harms society:
  • Basing public policy on the lie that homosexuals do not have the right to marry when they have the exact same right to marry as all citizens - does harm society. (see The "Gay's Can't Marry" Myth)

  • Redefining the Equal Protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment from applying to citizens to applying to relationships (see Equal Protection Under the Law) then refusing to apply that new definition to ALL relationships (e.g. polygamy, polyamory) - does harm society.

  • Claiming there is no difference between the two genders and teaching children that - does harm society.

  • Denying children either a father or a mother - does harm society.
  • Equating the civil rights movement, which showed that race is an inherent and inconsequential part of the design of human beings, with the claim of sexual orientation (a sexual desire for one's own sex that is at odds with their physical sexual genitalia) - does harm society. (See The Foundation for Human Rights)

  • Claiming that the federal and state constitutions (e.g. Massachusetts), which were written by men living in a society that believed that homosexual acts were an abomination of the laws of nature, actually allow homosexual relationships - does harm society.

  • Refusing to allow citizens of your state (again reference Massachusetts) to vote on a constitutional amendment making marriage between one man and one woman - does harm society.

  • Circumventing state constitutions (e.g. Oregon), which states that marriage is between one man and one woman, by granting all the rights of marriage to homosexual relationships by calling it civil unions or domestic partnerships - does harm society.

  • Having judges strike down a law passed by 61% of the voters in the country's most populace state (i.e. California) that explicitly defined the understood definition of marriage (one man - one woman) in that state - does harm society.

  • Then, having those same California judges refuse to offer a stay of their decision AFTER an marriage amendment (adding the struck down marriage definition to the constitution) was added to the November ballot thereby allowing marriage licenses to be issued to same-sex couples and creating chaos should the amendment pass - does harm society.
  • Claiming that defining marriage as one man-one woman is a ban on same-sex marriage while completely ignoring that it would also be a ban on other types of relationships (e.g. polygamy, polyamory) - does harm society. (see California's Top Court Legalizes Polygamy)

  • Demonizing and marginalizing those who disagree with same-sex marriage as Holmes did in his letter - does harm society.

Willful violations of constitutions by judges and legislatures. Redefinition of constitutional concepts. Circumventing the will of the people. Hijacking the civil rights movement. Assassinating the character of those who stand in opposition.

This is only a partial list of harm that same-sex marriage advocates have wrought upon our society.

Sunday, July 06, 2008

Forcing One's Morality on Others - Part III

On May 28, 2008 the following letter to the editor by Paul Holmes that appeared in the Columbian (Vancouver, WA) newspaper attacking Christianity's view of homosexual behavior. The person named White is a letter writer to which Holmes is responding. My comments are in italics:

This is the third in a four part series.

Paul Holmes writes:
Third, I would expect White, if he is a practicing Christian, to not engage in homosexual activities. That would certainly be against his beliefs. But keep the practice of your beliefs within you own circle of believers.

Holmes' belief that one should "keep the practice of your beliefs within your own circle of believers" is his belief. He is saying that others who do not share his particular beliefs regarding homosexuality should abide by his belief. That is hypocritical.

By the way, since Holmes was worried about adhering only to what the gospels say, Jesus did have something explicit to say about hypocrisy (see Matthew 7:1-6). Namely, don't do it.

And, of course, Jesus commanded his followers to "go and make disciples of all nations ... and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you." (Mt 28:19-20)

If Holmes is really worried about Christians following what Jesus and the Gospels taught, he would be praising Christians for not keeping "the practice of [their] beliefs within [their] own circle of believers." Praise is not forth coming because adherence to Jesus' teachings is not Holmes' goal.

There is something even more troubling than Holmes' self-refuting morality. In his letter, White directed his comments at Christians. White states, "what are you Christians thinking when you vote for a lifestyle contrary to the teachings of Christ." Holmes is condemning White precisely for "practicing his beliefs within his own circle of believers."


It appears that Holmes believes that Christians should not have a voice nor have a vote in matters where they do not agree with Holmes' worldview.

That view is profoundly arrogant in its anti-intellectualism.

Next post: Holmes' claim that If Christians must crusade to do so against divorce which "tens of millions" of Christians have engaged and to leave gays and lesbians have equal protection under the law.

Thursday, July 03, 2008

Forcing One's Morality on Others - Part II

On May 28, 2008 the following letter to the editor by Paul Holmes that appeared in the Columbian (Vancouver, WA) newspaper attacking Christianity's view of homosexual behavior. My comments are in italics:

This is the second in a four part series.

Paul Holmes writes:
Second, in reading the four gospels (Christ’s actual words and teachings) it is a long stretch to even find a reference to homosexuality.

Therefore, what? The unstated premise is that whatever is not mentioned in the gospels is okay. By this logic, Holmes would have to say gay-bashing and child molestation are okay since neither is mentioned in the gospels. I doubt Holmes would go there which brings us back to what exactly is Holmes' point.

Second, refer to my point in "Forcing One's Morality on Others - Part I" regarding Jesus being the Hebrew God who did have something to say about homosexual behavior.

Next post: Christians should keep their beliefs to themselves.

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

Forcing One's Morality on Others - Part I

On May 28, 2008, the following letter to the editor by Paul Holmes appeared in the Columbian (Vancouver, WA) newspaper attacking Christianity's view of homosexual behavior. My comments are in italics.

This is part one in a four part series.

Keep morals to yourself
I must disagree on so many levels with David White’s positions in his May 23 letter, "Agenda is morally wrong," and his question "Do you think His will … is to promote a lifestyle that he calls an abomination?"

First, Christ never called the homosexual lifestyle "an abomination." That was Paul, who never knew Jesus.

This is a sign that the person really doesn't know much about Christianity. First, Christ called himself the Son of God. That is a claim to deity. Not any deity but the God of the Hebrew Scriptures, which very clearly calls homosexual behavior an "abomination".

Further, Jesus stated "I have not come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them." (Matthew 5:17) Clearly, Jesus called the homosexual lifestyle an abomination.

Holmes provides no evidence to support his claim that Paul never knew Jesus. Luke writes of Paul meeting Jesus on the road to Damascus (Acts 9). In Acts 26:15-17, Luke recounts the words of Jesus to Paul, "I have appeared to you to appoint you as a servant and as a witness of what you have seen of me and what I will show you."

This is the same Paul, who repeatedly calls himself an apostle and servant of Christ (see the beginnings of Paul's letters, e.g. Romans, 1 & 2 Timothy, etc). An apostle is one who is commissioned by Christ. How can Paul be commissioned by one he supposedly never knew?

So Holmes' very first claim is false.

Next post: Holmes' claim that there is no reference to homosexuality in the four gospels.